PDA

View Full Version : 應用倫理 Applying Ethics: A Text with Readings


Daniel_Cheung
03-24-2011, 02:03 PM
由於找工作需要,我早晚也要讀這本書,所以想順便一問,各位有沒有興趣在七至十月時讀一讀?

Applying Ethics: A Text with Readings, 10th Edition
Julie C. Van Camp - California State University, Long Beach
Jeffrey Olen - Regis College
Vincent Barry - Bakersfield College, Emeritus
ISBN-10: 0495807958 ISBN-13: 9780495807957
576 Pages PB

出版商網頁 (http://www.cengage.com/search/productOverview.do?Ntt=applying%20ethics||9780495807957&Ntk=all||P_Isbn13&Ns=P_CopyRight_Year|1&N=0#mainTab_2)(可看到書裡各章的題目)


此類書籍內容十分典型,沒有很特別之處,但卻又是很多人想多了解和爭議的課題。

不過,此書最大的問題是價錢昂貴,amazon.com的二手書也要 US$76。我會建議買二手舊版,但我們要比較一下,小心不要選讀一些舊版沒有的文章。此書應該在各大學圖書館裡皆可找到的。





Preface.
PART I: MORAL REASONING.

1. Moral Reasons.

Moral Reasoning. Individual Morality and Social Morality. Ethical Relativism. Principles of Individual Morality. Principles of Social Morality. Summary and Conclusions. Readings: "Moral Virtue," Aristotle. "Respect for Persons," Immanuel Kant. "Utilitarianism," John Stuart Mill. "A Theory of Justice," John Rawls. "The Ethics of Care," Virginia Held.

2. Good Reasoning.

Arguments. Evaluating Moral Arguments. Summary and Conclusions.

PART II: ISSUES.

3. Sexual Morality.

The Traditional View. The Libertarian View. Treating Sex Differently. Arguments for Sexual Libertarianism. Arguments against Sexual Libertarianism. Readings: "Declaration on Certain Questions Concerning Sexual Ethics," The Vatican. "Sexual Morality and the Concept of Using Another Person," Thomas A. Mappes. "Should a Feminist Choose a Marriage-Like Relationship?" Marjorie Weinzweig. "The Case for Lesbian and Gay Marriage," Richard D. Mohr. Case Presentations: Disease v. Promiscuity? Lawrence v. Texas: Private Rights and Public Morality. Goodridge v. Dept. of Public Health: A Right of Gay Marriage. A Slippery Slope to Polygamy?

4. Abortion.

Biological Background . The Moral Problem. The Ontological Status of the Fetus. The Moral Status of the Fetus. Pro-Life Arguments (against Abortion). Pro-Choice Arguments (for Abortion).Readings: "Why Abortion is Immoral," Donald Marquis. "A Defense of Abortion," Judith Jarvis Thomson. "On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion," Mary Anne Warren. "Virtue Theory and Abortion," Rosalind Hursthouse. Case Presentations: Conceived in Violence, Born in Hate. Death in Pensacola. The Fight for Martina Greywind’s Baby. Sex-Selection Abortions.

5. Euthanasia.

Personhood. Death. Ordinary vs. Extraordinary Treatment. Killing vs. Allowing to Die. Meaning of Euthanasia: Narrow vs. Broad Interpretations. Voluntary vs. Nonvoluntary Euthanasia. Assisted Suicide. The Right to Refuse Treatment. Defective Newborns. Arguments for Voluntary (Active) Euthanasia. Arguments against Voluntary (Active) Euthanasia. Readings: "The Wrongfulness of Euthanasia," J. Gay-Willians. "Voluntary Active Euthanasia," Dan W. Brock. "Active and Passive Euthanasia," James Rachels. "Gender, Feminism, and Death: Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia," Susan M. Wolf. Case Presentations: "I Did It Because I Loved My Son." "A Choice Central to Personal Dignity." Legalized Assisted Suicide and Decriminalized Euthanasia. Terri Schiavo: Voluntary Euthanasia or Murder?

6. Genetic Engineering, Stem Cell Research, and Human Cloning.

How Cloning Works: A Brief History. Why Clone Humans? Moral and Legal Issues. Stem Cell Research. Arguments against Human Cloning. Arguments for Human Cloning. Readings: "The Case against Perfection," Michael J. Sandel. "Moral Status of Cloning Humans," Michael Tooley. "The Morality of Killing Human Embryos," Bonnie Steinbock. "Stem Cells, Biotechnology, and Human Rights: Implications for a Posthuman Future," Paul Lauritzen. Case Presentations: Recommendations of the President’s Council on Bioethics. A Birth to Save a Life. Presidential Policy. Eight is Enough.

7. Capital Punishment.

The Nature and Definition of Punishment. The Moral Acceptability of Punishment. Aims of Punishment. Retentionist and Abolitionist Defined. Capital Punishment as Deterrent. Abolitionist Arguments (against Capital Punishment). Retentionist Arguments (for Capital Punishment). Readings: "Speech in Favor of Capital Punishment," John Stuart Mill. "A Life for a Life," Igor Primoratz. "On Deterrence and the Death Penalty," Ernest Van Den Haag. "Capital Punishment and Social Defense," Hugo Adam Bedau. Case Presentations: Karla Faye Tucker and Stanley "Tookie" Williams: Rehabilitation on Death Row? A Failed Experiment? Warren McClesky. Punishing Child Rapists.

8. War, Terrorism, and Civil Liberties.

Just War Theory. Preemptive Wars. Violence and Terrorism. Jihadism. Pacifism. Civil Liberties. Arguments for Trading Civil Liberties for Safety. Arguments against Trading Civil Liberties for Safety. Readings: "The Triumph of Just War Theory (and the Dangers of Success)," Michael Walzer. "Violence, Terrorism, and Justice," R.G. Frey and Christopher W. Morris. "Make Torture an Option," Alan M. Dershowitz. "Torture and the Ticking Bomb," David Luban. Case Presentations: Preemptive War. Driving While Veiled. Fear of Flying. The Geneva Conventions and Guantanamo Bay.

9. Globalization and Social Justice.

Globalization. Distribution Justice. Equality, Need, and Merit. Libertarianism, Welfare Liberalism, and Socialism. Argument for Global Aid. Arguments against Global Aid. Readings: "What We Owe to the Global Poor," Mathias Risse. "Sweatshops and Respect for Persons," Denis G. Arnold and Norman E. Bowie. "Illegal Immigrants, Health Care, and Social Responsibility," James F. Dwyer. "Female Genital Circumcision and Conventionalist Ethical Relativism," Loretta M. Kopelman. Case Presentations: Stopping the Sweatshops. Is There a Right to Health Care? Do Illegal Immigrants Have a Right to Education? Yearning to Breathe Free.

10. Discrimination.

Discrimination: Its Nature and Forms. Evidence of Discrimination. Affirmative Action: Preferential Treatment? Arguments against Affirmative Action. Arguments for Affirmative Action. Readings: "The Justification of Reverse Discrimination," Tom L. Beauchamp. "A Defense of Programs of Preferential Treatment," Richard Wasserstrom. "Reverse Discrimination as Unjustified," Lisa Newton. "Class, Not Race," Richard Kahlenberg. Case Presentations: Proposition 209. Grutter v. Bollinger: Taking Race into Account. Reparations: An Overdue Debt to African Slaves in America? Friendly Sexual Harassment?

11. Animal Rights and Environmental Ethics.

What Do We Owe Nonhuman Animals? What’s Wrong with Speciesism? Environmental Ethics. Environmental Problems. The Moral Issue. Why Environmental Ethics? Arguments for Ethical Treatment of Animals and the Environment. Arguments Against Ethical Treatment of Animals and the Environment. Readings: "All Animals Are Equal or Why Supporters of Liberation for Blacks and Women Should Support Animal Liberation Too," Peter Singer. "The Case for Animal Rights," Tom Regan. "Do Animals Have Rights?" Carl Cohen. "The Ethics of Respect for Nature," Paul W. Taylor. Case Presentations: Animal Liberators. Religious Sacrifice. A Metaphor for the Energy Debate. The Spotted Owl.

12. Computer Ethics and the Internet.

What Is Computer Ethics? Issues in Computer Ethics. Arguments in Favor of Ethical Conduct With Computers and the Internet. Arguments against Ethical conduct With Computers and the Internet. Readings: "The Constitution in Cyberspace: Law and Liberty Beyond the Electronic Frontier," Laurence H. Tribe. "Free Speech in Cyberspace," Richard A. Spinello. "Is it Moral to Make Copies of Software for My Friends?" Bernard Gert. "Cyberstalking, Personal Privacy, and Moral Responsibility," Herman T. Tavani and Frances S. Grodzinsky. Case Presentations: Ticketed for Obscenity on the Information Superhighway. A Chill in Cyberspace. Censoring Political Speech. Pirates of the Campuses.

AFTERWORD.
GLOSSARY.
INDEX.

sbchan
03-24-2011, 03:32 PM
這是典型的應用倫理學教科書,市面上很多種類,不過,如果反正都是要讀,不如用Norris 編的那一本吧,也是很好的,我教應用倫理時用過. ^_^

http://www.amazon.com/Applied-Ethics-Multicultural-Approach-5th/dp/0205708080/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1300998661&sr=8-2

Daniel_Cheung
03-24-2011, 06:23 PM
這是典型的應用倫理學教科書,市面上很多種類,不過,如果反正都是要讀,不如用Norris 編的那一本吧,也是很好的,我教應用倫理時用過. ^_^

http://www.amazon.com/Applied-Ethics-Multicultural-Approach-5th/dp/0205708080/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1300998661&sr=8-2

我猜想你喜歡這書的原因之一是這書選的課題比較國際化和宏觀,例如多談人權、公義和戰爭等,但上述那書卻比較多選個人或社會性的課題,例如性解放和電腦技術產生的倫理問題。另外,上述那書另一好處是簡談一點思考方法,教導讀者如何分析論證。而且,Norris 也未必有空來談。

不過,這視乎各位的喜好,我沒所謂。

sbchan
03-24-2011, 07:29 PM
我猜想你喜歡這書的原因之一是這書選的課題比較國際化和宏觀,例如多談人權、公義和戰爭等,但上述那書卻比較多選個人或社會性的課題,例如性解放和電腦技術產生的倫理問題。另外,上述那書另一好處是簡談一點思考方法,教導讀者如何分析論證。而且,Norris 也未必有空來談。

不過,這視乎各位的喜好,我沒所謂。

嗯,Norris 那書的好處是多談文化差異,比較適合我要教的東西。至於偏向社會政治的如公義和戰爭,又或個人點的如性解放等,其實兩本書都一樣有。暫時留意到的不同是NOrris 的書有談文化與人權,你提及的書則特別有談電腦問題。

當然,我也只是提議下,也是沒有太大所謂的. ^_^

horace
03-25-2011, 02:30 AM
ch. 6,7,8,9,10,12的topic有興趣﹐其他的topic讀PHIL120時已經看過了。

pilgrim
03-27-2011, 08:32 PM
How about we ask if Norris will be available to participate in the study if we pick his book? Having Norris to give feedback and guidance on his own book will be a great contribution to the study!

Daniel_Cheung
03-28-2011, 10:37 PM
How about we ask if Norris will be available to participate in the study if we pick his book? Having Norris to give feedback and guidance on his own book will be a great contribution to the study!

他好像忙到沒有查看 pm 了。

Daniel_Cheung
04-06-2011, 02:37 PM
想了想,還是用 Applied Ethics (http://www.amazon.com/Applied-Ethics-Multicultural-Approach-5th/dp/0205708080/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1302118014&sr=1-1)那書吧,有幾個原因的:

一,比較便宜
二,內容比較國際化
三,編者之一(Dr. Kai Wong)有可能會來
四,Dr. Benedict Chan 曾用來教學
五,那出版商比較大方,送了一本給我,那麼我比較方便拿來閱讀:p

對於一般信徒讀者來說,學習一下這些應用倫理學課題是很重要的,主要原因有二:

一,在教會裡,我們很少有足夠相關資料去對課題作出深入了解,以致判斷往往流於膚淺,以為讀過幾篇一、兩千字的教報文章就足夠。
二,基督徒的倫理觀不一定要跟非信徒的倫理觀 opposite 的,讀這類書籍可以幫助信徒讀者了解其他背景的人士的看法,從中參長補短。


正如一般做法,有興趣朋友請自行找這書,按我們稍後公布的時間表來這裡一起討論便可。(新朋友須登記方有發言權。)時段大約是七至十月。若您找到一本舊版書,請小心查看我們將會閱讀的文章是否都在那書裡。謝謝!

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51pZXRiva8L._BO2,204,203,200_PIsitb-sticker-arrow-click,TopRight,35,-76_AA300_SH20_OU01_.jpg (http://www.amazon.com/Applied-Ethics-Multicultural-Approach-5th/dp/0205708080/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1302118014&sr=1-1)

sbchan
04-06-2011, 09:56 PM
我那時用的是第四版,我也沒第五版....:p

Daniel_Cheung
04-09-2011, 11:06 AM
五,那出版商比較大方,送了一本給我,那麼我比較方便拿來閱讀:p


本來沒有送書給我的那出版社,剛又寄了兩本來。:confused:
不過,還是用 Applied Ethics 吧。

horace
04-13-2011, 12:54 AM
點樣可以叫出版社送書咁好?

Daniel_Cheung
04-13-2011, 08:27 AM
點樣可以叫出版社送書咁好?

這是大學教授或研究生的專利 :p
它們認為這些人的決定可以帶來幾十以至數百本書的生意。

Daniel_Cheung
06-04-2011, 01:57 PM
由我發起的學系內的應用倫理討論小組終於開始了。日前跟系內同學讀了兩篇環保倫理,都是來自這兩本書的相關文章。讀後的感想是,難怪這類科目不為很多哲學教授視作嚴肅的哲學,例如那兩篇文章的論證皆十分草率,很多較深入的問題沒有處理。有同學謔稱,這些文章只是用來令學生停一停,發現自己固有思想也可以被挑戰而已,這也稱得上達到了某些教學目的。

我希望只是那兩篇文章比較差而已。

話說來,我們說七月會開始讀 Applied Ethics 一書,其實有多少朋友打算如此?若原來是沒有的,我閒時把那裡的小組討論整理一下,貼在這裡就算了,屆時各位想談便接著談一談。

Daniel_Cheung
06-08-2011, 12:38 AM
正在看 Robert Elliot, "Faking Nature" 一文(此觀點後發展為同名的一本書)。他的觀點好像有點怪,說出來看看各位怎樣想:

他要談的是,有一類破壞環境人士的言論認為,只要他們事後把一切都復回原狀,那就沒問題啦!例如,採礦後重新種植回那裡本來有的植物,或河流因公路而改道,但改道時一切生態仍然保留,那河流還是彎彎曲曲的,河裡的動物還在那裡等。

作者認為,即使假設那些復完工作做得十分完滿,這樣的言論還是可被批評的。其中一個要點是,自然的其中一個 "property" 就是不經人手安排,環境被破壞了,人為地再復原,已經失去了這樣一個 "property" 。

這不期然令我想到初戀。即使戀愛還是戀愛,但第一次總是最特別的。不過,作者沒有用這例子(他太強調問題在於 faking ,所以應該不會用這例子)。作者提出的其他例子包括,名畫與一個完全一樣的仿製品,永遠都是有分別的。

然而,究竟失去了甚麼東西,彷彿是大問題?留意,在他的假設裡,復原工作是十分完滿的,根本沒有甚麼東西失掉了,所以他的反對理由並不是「這還是跟原本的有差別,有欠缺」。難道「渾然天成」真的是一種 property ?:confused:


即是真的是一種 property ,沒有了它是否很大件事*?這個要求某東西在某時某地出現,形而上學有稱為一種叫做 thisness 的 property ,但這概念十分玄妙。(未知他有否在書裡談論。)

作者又提出, causal continuity with the rest of the environment 也是重要的東西。


(*問是否很大件事,可能作者會不滿,因他曾說他針對的只是理論上沒可能完全復完,而不是這有多重要。不過,這顯然就是此觀點接著要說的。)

yanlaptak
06-10-2011, 11:16 PM
報名

Daniel_Cheung
06-14-2011, 12:21 AM
報名

暫時看來,我要到十月才會有空讀這書,並且可能會進展緩慢,若甄兄不介意,小弟樂意奉陪。(現在我跟一些學系裡的研究生有討論相關課題,但不是用這書。)