加爾文主義在拉斯維加斯機場

[Daniel Zou]

我不知道該不該把這個thread寫在這裡，如果不合适，請版主隨便移。 :)

http://webmasters2go.com/danielz/Calvinism_Oct%2016,%202005.pdf

這是今夏我在多倫多所屬的教會發起的閲讀比賽的一片參賽文章。我選擇的書籍是Fuller神學院院長 Richard Mouw的新作 Calvinism in Las Vegas Airport。本書的目的是將看似古老的加爾文主義與我們所処的21世紀聯係起來。特別是對於不了解加爾文主義的基督徒，本書將是很好的入門讀物。

小弟寫了這篇讀書報告，不敢說包含全部精彩内容，只希望能夠將其精意呈現出來。歡迎大家閲讀指正。

[wonggk]

我不知道該不該把這個thread寫在這裡，如果不合适，請版主隨便移。 :)

http://webmasters2go.com/danielz/Calvinism_Oct%2016,%202005.pdf

這是今夏我在多倫多所屬的教會發起的閲讀比賽的一片參賽文章。我選擇的書籍是Fuller神學院院長 Richard Mouw的新作 Calvinism in Las Vegas Airport。本書的目的是將看似古老的加爾文主義與我們所処的21世紀聯係起來。特別是對於不了解加爾文主義的基督徒，本書將是很好的入門讀物。

小弟寫了這篇讀書報告，不敢說包含全部精彩内容，只希望能夠將其精意呈現出來。歡迎大家閲讀指正。

I happen to be a strong opponent of Calvinism. Because I can't read simplified Chinese very well, I was only able to briefly scan your article. Do you have a traditional Chinese version available?

You may also check out a chapter in this book on Calvinism.
http://www.hvpoint.com/series08d.htm
This is my book and the chapter on Calvinism was co-written by Norris Wong and I. Although the writing style is not very academic, I think that we have covered a lot of grounds on the topic and some of the references at the end will be useful to you.

Unfortunately, I don't think you can buy the book in North America yet. I am working (but very slowly) on distributing it in North America. If you (or any other folks here) are interested, send me your email address and I will email a file to you.

[Daniel Zou]

http://webmasters2go.com/danielz/Calvinism_traditional.pdf

歡迎指正，謝謝！ :)

[Daniel Zou]

my email address is daniel_littleprince@yahoo.ca, I'd like to read your work very much! :) Thanks.

[Daniel_Cheung]

鄒亮，你有看過我寫的那個開放神論系列嗎？
http://www.christiantimes.org.hk/Common/Reader/News/ShowNews.jsp?Nid=30199&Pid=2&Version=934&Cid=105&Charset=big5_hkscs
http://www.christiantimes.org.hk/Common/Reader/News/ShowNews.jsp?Nid=30297&Pid=2&Version=935&Cid=105&Charset=big5_hkscs
http://www.christiantimes.org.hk/Common/Reader/News/ShowNews.jsp?Nid=30399&Pid=2&Version=936&Cid=105&Charset=big5_hkscs
http://www.christiantimes.org.hk/Common/Reader/News/ShowNews.jsp?Nid=30527&Pid=2&Version=937&Cid=105&Charset=big5_hkscs

我其實應該仔細看你的文章然後回應的，但這幾個星期太忙碌了，要看basic writings，要預備邏輯班，要在教會帶查經，要見教授．．．．．．，恐怕有空閒時已經是十一月，所以唯有貼這幾個連結出來，在這系列了，我沒有很正面討論加爾文主義，但我不時都會提及加爾文主義，並且質疑其中一些觀點。

[wonggk]

http://webmasters2go.com/danielz/Calvinism_traditional.pdf

歡迎指正，謝謝！ :)
I read your article once. I am no way close to 指正 anything. We are all here to learn and share. And my comments here are more related to the original book than your paper.

One disappointment I have is that I cannot find much discussion on why arguments against Calvinism are incorrect. I don't know whether Mouw had presented any insight in his book to rebut arguments against Calvinism, or you find it unnecessary to mention them. But that was my impression with many Calvinists. I have yet to see a strong logical defense on why arguments against Calvinism are wrong. They just ignore questions then cannot answer, and often just fall back to the argument of "God's sovereignty, man cannot understand". Daniel Cheung’s paper on open theism also had some discussion on this issue too.

Let us continue after you have a chance to read my book and Daniel (Cheung)’s paper